Source: Kataeb.org
Monday 16 November 2026 08:27:59
As the United Nations Interim Force in Lebanon (UNIFIL) prepares to end its mission, a proposal to replace the peacekeeping force with an international observer mission modeled on the experience in Egypt's Sinai Peninsula is emerging as a possible framework for future security arrangements in southern Lebanon.
The proposal would mark a shift from a large international military presence to a smaller monitoring mission equipped with surveillance technology, protection units and liaison teams. Its primary task would be to verify compliance with security arrangements, particularly restrictions on weapons and military deployments.
But whether the Sinai model can be replicated in southern Lebanon remains an open question, given the differences between the two territories and the absence of a peace agreement between Lebanon and Israel.
The Multinational Force and Observers (MFO) has monitored the implementation of security arrangements in Sinai since the signing of the Egyptian-Israeli peace treaty in 1979. Its mandate includes verifying compliance with restrictions on the deployment of military forces in designated areas through international observers and field-monitoring mechanisms.
In theory, a similar arrangement could provide a framework for southern Lebanon after UNIFIL's departure, particularly if it secured U.S.-French backing and the approval of the Lebanese government.
Under the proposed approach, southern Lebanon could be divided into security zones, Nidaa Al-Watan newspaper reported. The first would run along the border, extending up to two kilometers inland, and would be kept free of military presence. A second zone stretching toward the Litani River would see the Lebanese army deploy, while international observers would conduct inspections and verify that weapons remain exclusively in state hands.
Such an arrangement would seek to combine a Lebanese military presence with international monitoring, providing a mechanism to verify the dismantling of unauthorized weapons and military infrastructure.
However, the differences between Sinai and southern Lebanon are substantial.
The MFO operates under a peace treaty between Egypt and Israel, which provides an agreed legal and political framework for monitoring the two sides' security commitments. Lebanon and Israel, by contrast, have no peace treaty. Their current arrangements are based on a cessation of hostilities and security understandings that remain contested, while Israel continues to occupy parts of Lebanese territory and carry out repeated attacks.
This raises a fundamental question about the proposed mission: Would international observers be tasked with verifying the commitments of both sides, including an Israeli withdrawal, or would they primarily monitor Lebanon while leaving Israel to determine what constitutes a security threat and how to respond?
The distinction is critical. If the observers' role is limited to documenting developments on the ground, while Israel retains freedom of military action and the ability to impose its own security conditions, the resulting arrangement would bear little resemblance to the Sinai model.
Instead, international monitoring could become a cover for security arrangements imposed by Israel inside Lebanese territory, effectively creating areas under Israeli security control despite their remaining under Lebanese civilian administration.
The proposal also comes against the backdrop of UNIFIL's planned withdrawal. Established in 1978 under Security Council Resolutions 425 and 426 to confirm Israel's withdrawal, restore security and help the Lebanese government extend its authority, the force saw its mandate expanded after the 2006 war under Resolution 1701.
The resolution increased UNIFIL's troop ceiling to 15,000 and called for an area between the Blue Line and the Litani River to be free of weapons and armed personnel other than those belonging to the Lebanese state and UNIFIL.
Successive Security Council resolutions attempted to strengthen the force's operational capacity. Resolution 2650 in 2022 clarified that UNIFIL did not require prior authorization to carry out its mandated activities, while Resolution 2695 in 2023 reaffirmed its operational independence alongside continued coordination with the Lebanese government. Resolution 2749 renewed its mandate in 2024 amid the war.
The latest decision, Resolution 2790, adopted on Aug. 28, 2025, authorized a final extension until Dec. 31, 2026, followed by a drawdown and withdrawal over the subsequent year. The end of UNIFIL's presence has therefore been decided, although the withdrawal process has yet to be completed.
The future security arrangement also faces the consequences of the failure to fully implement previous understandings.
The November 2024 understanding provided for the Lebanese army to deploy and dismantle unauthorized military infrastructure in parallel with an Israeli withdrawal, with support from a U.S.-French monitoring mechanism. However, the army failed to establish an effective and lasting monopoly over security and weapons.
The failure reflected not only military limitations but also Lebanon's divided political decision-making, Hezbollah's continued possession of weapons, the Israeli occupation and repeated Israeli attacks.
A trilateral framework agreement reached on June 26, 2026, subsequently introduced a gradual and conditional implementation process involving pilot areas, verification of the dismantling of weapons and military infrastructure, Lebanese army deployments and phased Israeli withdrawals under U.S. supervision. However, it did not assign UNIFIL a specific role.
With implementation still limited, there are concerns that responsibility could shift from a Lebanese-led process backed by international support to externally imposed arrangements determining the conditions under which Lebanon can restore control over its territory.
Ultimately, the viability of a Sinai-inspired mission in southern Lebanon would depend on three fundamental guarantees: explicit Lebanese state approval, a clear commitment to Israeli withdrawal and respect for Lebanese sovereignty, and a balanced mandate empowering international observers to verify both sides' obligations.
Without these conditions, the proposed mission risks becoming an instrument for monitoring Lebanon rather than ensuring compliance by both parties. What is presented as an international security arrangement could then turn into a system of Israeli-imposed security zones inside Lebanon, with the Lebanese state retaining civilian administration but lacking full control over the territory.